
If your online store shows the wrong price, you are not automatically bound to sell at it. A public product listing is usually treated as an invitation for customers to make offers, not as an offer that a click can accept. The contract normally forms when your business accepts the order, and a checkout that confirms orders automatically can do that for you within minutes. A seller can escape a pricing mistake only in narrow cases, such as where the buyer actually knew it was an error. This guide explains how the rules work and how to set up your store so a typing mistake does not become a binding sale.

Is a product listing on your website an offer?
Usually not. Singapore’s Electronic Transactions Act 2010 deals with this in section 14. A proposal to make a contract that is made through electronic communications, is generally accessible, and is not addressed to specific people is to be considered an invitation to make offers. The Act says this covers proposals made through interactive applications for ordering goods or services. The exception is where the proposal clearly shows that the business intends to be bound if it is accepted. You can read the Act on Singapore Statutes Online.
In practice, a normal web shop listing does not say “if you order this, we are bound”. The customer’s order is therefore the offer, and your business decides whether to accept it. That gives you a real chance to catch a pricing error, but only if your checkout is built so that acceptance is a separate step.
If your listing, banner or terms do say that an order is accepted the moment it is placed, you have moved the point of acceptance forward. The wording of the page matters as much as the law.
When is a sale concluded: at the order, the confirmation or the dispatch?
The answer depends on what your checkout tells the customer and what your system does. Most stores send an automatic email saying “Order received” or “Thank you for your order”. Some then send a second email when the goods are dispatched. A sale that is concluded at the order stage leaves you no time to check the price. A sale that is concluded only at dispatch leaves you a window.
The leading Singapore case on online pricing mistakes is Chwee Kin Keong and others v Digilandmall.com Pte Ltd [2005] SGCA 2, reported at [2005] 1 SLR(R) 502. An employee of a related company changed the price of a colour laser printer on the seller’s websites from about S$3,854 to S$66. Six buyers ordered 4,086 printers between them. The seller refused to supply. On when contracts were made, the Court of Appeal applied ordinary contract principles to internet contracts and treated a contract as prima facie concluded where the order was followed by the system recording a successful transaction and then sending a confirmation email within minutes. The judgment is on eLitigation.
The same Act, in section 15, says a contract formed by the interaction of an automated system and a person, or between two automated systems, is not invalid just because no human looked at each action or at the resulting contract. A store cannot say, after the fact, that nobody on staff approved the order.
When can a seller escape a wrong price?
In Chwee Kin Keong, the Court of Appeal held that, at common law, a contract is void for unilateral mistake only if the other party actually knew of the mistake. Constructive knowledge, meaning that the buyer ought to have realised, is not enough at common law. The court also recognised a separate equitable power to set contracts aside, which needs more than constructive knowledge: there must be some impropriety, such as sharp practice, and deliberately staying silent about a suspected mistake can qualify. Knowledge is a question of fact, usually worked out from the surrounding circumstances, and wilful blindness can count.
Applying that test, the court found that some buyers knew or must have known that S$66 was a mistake and upheld the finding that their contracts were void or could be set aside. It reached that view buyer by buyer, on the evidence of what each did and said.
The practical lessons for a seller are cautious ones:
- An ordinary shopper who buys one item at a bargain price, and has no reason to suspect an error, is a hard target for a mistake argument.
- Evidence of knowledge matters: messages between buyers, unusually large orders, or checks the buyer made before ordering.
- Each buyer is judged on their own facts. Do not assume that a mistake defeats every order at the wrong price.
- The case turned on very unusual facts. Do not rely on it as a general right to cancel orders when you make an error.
What should you do the moment you spot the error?
- Correct the listing immediately and note the time. Every order after that point is made at the right price.
- Pause automatic fulfilment for the affected product so that no more goods are shipped or digital items released at the wrong price.
- Export every order placed at the wrong price, with time stamps, quantities, customer details, and the confirmation emails sent.
- Read your own terms to see when you say the contract is concluded and whether you reserved a right to cancel for pricing errors.
- Separate the orders. Single ordinary orders, bulk orders and orders that look suspicious may need different handling.
- Contact customers promptly and honestly. Explain the error, offer a refund or the right price, and keep copies of what you send. Delay may look like acceptance.
- Take advice before cancelling a large batch or refusing to supply, especially where the customers are consumers or the sums are large.
Many sellers choose to honour small orders as a goodwill cost and focus their legal position on bulk orders and orders where the buyer plainly knew the price was wrong. That is a commercial decision. It also reduces the risk of a complaint about unfair dealing with consumers.
What should your terms of sale say about pricing errors?
Good terms will not rescue a sale that your own checkout confirmed, but they set the customer’s expectations and give you a defensible process. Consider these clauses.
| Clause | What it does | Caution |
|---|---|---|
| Acceptance on dispatch | Says the order is an offer and the contract forms only when you send a dispatch or acceptance notice | Your order emails must match. An email saying “your order is confirmed” undermines the clause |
| Pricing errors | Allows you to cancel and refund an order where the displayed price was an obvious error | Keep it fair and specific. Terms that look one-sided may be challenged |
| Quantity limits | Caps units per customer on promotions | Display the limit on the product page, not only in the terms |
| Stock and availability | Says orders are subject to availability and what happens if stock runs out | Advertised promotions should be backed by realistic stock |
| Fraud or abuse | Lets you refuse or cancel orders that look fraudulent or abusive | Apply it consistently |
Terms only help if they form part of the contract before the order is accepted. Our article on whether website and app terms bind customers explains how to present them. Clauses that cut back your liability can also be tested for reasonableness, as we explain in our guide to exclusion clauses.
Do consumer rules limit how you handle a pricing mistake?
They can. Where your customers are consumers, the way you advertise prices and handle complaints can raise issues under consumer protection law, in addition to the contract rules above. Misleading price claims, discounts that are not real and promotions without realistic stock are the usual trouble spots. We cover them in our articles on price transparency for SMEs and misleading advertising and unfair practices. A genuine, promptly corrected error is a very different position from a “mistake” that appears every time a promotion needs traffic.
If you sell through a marketplace as well as your own site, read the platform’s seller terms. They may set their own rules for price errors, cancellations and seller performance, and these operate alongside your contract with the customer. For the wider legal set-up of an online business, see our guide to setting up an online business in Singapore.
Example: a hypothetical electronics retailer
Example: A small company sells headphones through its own web shop. A staff member enters S$29 instead of S$299 for a popular model. The checkout sends an email saying “Your order is confirmed” the moment payment clears. In the 40 minutes before anyone notices, 25 customers order one pair each, and one customer orders 60 pairs after posting about the “glitch” in a deals forum. The company corrects the price and pauses fulfilment. It decides to honour the single-unit orders as a goodwill cost and takes advice on the 60-unit order, since the forum post may be evidence that the buyer knew it was a mistake. It then changes its checkout so the first email says “Order received” and the contract forms on a dispatch notice, and adds a clear pricing error clause to its terms.
The company, figures and outcome are invented for illustration and do not describe a real case.
What checklist should an online seller keep?
- A written price-change procedure with a second person checking before a price goes live.
- Order emails that match your terms about when the contract is made.
- Maximum quantity limits for promotions and a way to flag unusually large orders.
- Time-stamped logs of price changes, orders and customer emails.
- Terms of sale that are visible before checkout and cover pricing errors, availability and cancellation.
- A standard customer message for correcting an error and offering a refund.
- A named person who decides whether to honour or cancel affected orders.
Frequently asked questions
Can I cancel an order just because the price was a typing error?
Not automatically. If the contract has already formed, a typing error does not by itself undo it. The seller must rely on a contract term that allows cancellation, or on the narrow mistake rules, which usually need proof that the buyer knew of the error.
Does an “Order received” email mean a contract exists?
It depends on the wording and your terms. An email that only acknowledges receipt and says you will confirm later is easier to defend than one that says the order is confirmed. Make the wording and the terms consistent.
Does it matter if the buyer is a business and not a consumer?
The contract rules are the same, but consumer protection rules apply only to consumers. A business buyer who orders in bulk at an obviously wrong price may find it harder to say it did not suspect a mistake.
Should I refund and apologise, or fight?
For small, single orders by ordinary customers, many sellers refund or honour the order, because the cost is modest and the dispute is hard to win. For large or suspicious orders, get advice before deciding. The right choice depends on the evidence of what each buyer knew.
Does a pricing error clause in my terms always work?
No. It must be part of the contract before acceptance, it should be reasonable, and it cannot cure a checkout that tells the customer the sale is final. It is a safety net, not a substitute for price checks.
What if a marketplace platform ran the checkout?
The platform’s rules about price errors and cancellations may apply as well as your own terms. Read the seller terms before you decide how to respond, and keep records of what the platform’s system sent to customers.
Need help with an online pricing mistake or your terms of sale?
If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with an online pricing mistake or a review of your terms of sale, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles commercial contracts and consumer law. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.
The Raffles Corporate Services Editorial Team, Raffles Corporate Services
