Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

Earn-Outs and Completion Accounts in a Singapore Share Sale: Drafting the Price Mechanism

Two business partners shaking hands in agreement

An earn-out and completion accounts both exist to fix a gap between the price agreed at signing and what the business is really worth when the buyer takes over or in the years after. Completion accounts adjust the price once the numbers at the completion date are known. An earn-out makes part of the price depend on future performance. Disputes rarely come from the idea of adjusting the price. They come from vague definitions, unclear accounting policies and silence about who controls the business afterwards. This guide explains what to write into a Singapore share sale agreement so the price can be worked out without a fight.

Two business partners shaking hands in agreement
Buyer and seller agree how the price of a share sale will be fixed. Photo by Ambre Estève on Unsplash.

Why does a share sale need a price adjustment at all?

A buyer usually prices a company on figures that are weeks or months old. Between those figures and completion, the company keeps trading. Cash may be paid out, stock may be run down, customers may pay late, and a large liability may appear. If the price is a fixed number, one side carries all of that movement.

A price adjustment mechanism shares the risk by agreement. The buyer pays a headline price, then the parties compare an agreed set of measures at completion with the figures the headline price assumed. The difference moves the price up or down. An earn-out serves a different purpose: it bridges disagreement about the future, for example when the seller believes the business will grow faster than the buyer is willing to pay for today.

Neither tool replaces due diligence or warranties. Our articles on warranties and indemnities in a share purchase agreement and on legal due diligence for an SME acquisition cover those parts of the deal.

Completion accounts, locked box or earn-out: which fits your deal?

These are separate tools and a deal may use more than one. The table below compares them in plain terms.

Mechanism How the price is fixed Main risk Suits
Completion accounts Accounts are drawn up as at the completion date, then the price is adjusted for cash, debt and working capital Argument over accounting policies and judgement calls after completion Businesses whose cash and working capital move a lot between signing and completion
Locked box Price is fixed by reference to a past balance sheet date, and the seller promises no value leaks out after it Leakage between the balance sheet date and completion Stable businesses with clean, reliable accounts
Earn-out Part of the price is paid later if agreed targets are met Buyer control of the business, and how the target is measured Deals where the seller expects growth the buyer will not pay for upfront

The right choice depends on how reliable the accounts are, how quickly the deal completes, and how much trust sits between the parties. A founder who stays on to run the business may be comfortable with an earn-out. A seller who is leaving completely often prefers a fixed price, because an earn-out leaves the outcome in the buyer’s hands.

What must the agreement define for completion accounts?

Most completion account disputes trace back to a few missing definitions. Settle these in the agreement, not afterwards:

How should the completion accounts process run?

A workable process has fixed steps and fixed periods, with the length of each period agreed by the parties to suit the size of the business. A typical sequence:

  1. The buyer prepares draft completion accounts and a price calculation within an agreed number of days after completion.
  2. The seller receives the draft and the supporting records, with reasonable access to the company’s books, staff and advisers.
  3. The seller has an agreed period to accept the draft or serve a written notice of dispute. The notice must say which items are disputed, and why, with figures.
  4. Items not disputed become final. The parties negotiate the disputed items for an agreed period.
  5. If they cannot agree, the remaining items go to the decision-maker named in the agreement.
  6. The price is adjusted and payment is made within a short, fixed period after the final figures are settled.

Two drafting points save the most trouble. First, say that a notice of dispute that does not identify the items and amounts is not a valid notice. Second, say what happens if the buyer misses its own deadline to deliver the draft. A common answer is that the seller may prepare the accounts or may treat the buyer’s silence as acceptance of the estimate in the agreement.

Who should decide a price dispute: an expert or the court?

A narrow accounting disagreement, such as how to value stock under an agreed policy, is often sent to an independent accountant acting as an expert. The agreement usually says the person acts “as an expert and not as an arbitrator”, sets how the expert is chosen if the parties cannot agree, and allocates the expert’s fees. This is generally faster and cheaper than a full dispute process, but the exact legal effect depends on how the clause is worded, so have it drafted with care.

Keep the expert’s role narrow. A dispute over whether a warranty was broken, or whether the seller concealed a liability, is a legal question and belongs in the agreement’s normal dispute resolution clause. If the two are mixed, the parties may end up arguing about which forum owns which question before they argue about the price. Say clearly that the expert decides only the price calculation items, and that a warranty claim is not blocked just because an item was dealt with in the completion accounts, unless you intend it to be.

What makes an earn-out clause work?

An earn-out turns on three questions: what is measured, who controls the business, and what happens if something changes. Address each in the agreement.

Drafting point What to settle
The metric Revenue, gross profit or profit measure, defined by reference to specific accounting policies. Profit measures are easy to move with cost allocations, so state what may and may not be charged to the business
The earn-out period Start and end dates, and whether payments are annual or at the end
Targets and payment scale All-or-nothing, or a sliding scale between a floor and a cap. Sliding scales reduce cliff-edge disputes
Buyer conduct Whether the buyer must run the business in the ordinary course, keep it separate, avoid diverting customers or contracts to other group companies, and avoid changing accounting policies
Information rights The seller’s right to see management accounts and the earn-out calculation, and to query it within a stated period
Change of control or sale Whether the earn-out is accelerated, secured or assumed by a new owner if the buyer sells the business or the shares during the period
Set-off Whether the buyer may deduct agreed warranty claims from the earn-out, and how disputed claims are handled
Seller’s role Whether payment depends on the seller staying employed, and what happens if the seller leaves

The last row needs care. If the earn-out is linked to the seller continuing to work in the business, it can look more like pay for services than part of the price, which may affect how it is treated for tax and accounting. The agreement and the employment terms should be prepared together. Our guide to employment contracts in Singapore sets out the employer side of that conversation, and you should take tax advice on the treatment before signing.

Do stamp duty and accounting treatment affect the price terms?

They can. Stamp duty on a transfer of shares in a Singapore company is a cost of the deal, and the transfer instrument must be stamped within IRAS deadlines. The amount depends on IRAS’s rules for working out the dutiable value, which can involve the price paid or the value of the shares. Ask your tax adviser how a price that is partly deferred or contingent is dealt with. The IRAS guidance on stamp duty for shares is the starting point.

On the accounting side, a buyer that expects to pay an earn-out will normally need an estimate of it for its own accounts, and the estimate may need updating each year. Discuss this with the accountants early, because it affects the figures the earn-out clause will be tested against. If the sale is of assets rather than shares, the mechanics and tax differ, and our comparison of an asset sale and a share sale explains why.

Example: a hypothetical earn-out for a logistics business

Example: A founder sells all the shares in a freight forwarding company. The buyer pays a fixed amount at completion, a retained sum that is adjusted for working capital under completion accounts, and an earn-out based on gross profit over the next two financial years. The agreement says gross profit is calculated using the policies in a schedule, that group management charges cannot be deducted, and that the buyer may not move existing customer contracts into another group company during the period. It gives the founder a right to the monthly management accounts. At the end of the first year the buyer’s calculation falls short of the target. The founder serves a notice of dispute identifying two items, each with figures. The notice is valid because the agreement requires it to be specific, and the two items go to an independent accountant under the agreement. The parties never have to argue about what the process was, only about the numbers.

The figures, parties and outcome in this example are invented to show how the drafting works. They are not a real transaction.

What documents and information should you gather?

Frequently asked questions

Is an earn-out better for the buyer or the seller?

It depends on the drafting. An earn-out lets a buyer pay less upfront and shifts risk to the seller, but a seller can protect itself with conduct covenants, information rights and clear definitions. Without those protections the buyer holds most of the control.

Can the buyer change the business during the earn-out period?

Only as far as the agreement allows. If the agreement is silent, the seller may struggle to complain about ordinary commercial decisions. If the seller wants limits, such as keeping the business separate or not moving contracts, they should be written in.

What if the completion accounts show a lower price after completion?

The agreement should say who pays the difference and when. If part of the price is held back, the adjustment is usually taken from that sum first, with the seller paying any excess. A seller who has already spent the proceeds may struggle to repay, which is why retention is common.

Is a locked box simpler?

It can be, because there are no post-completion accounts to argue over. The trade-off is that the buyer takes the risk of the business between the locked box date and completion, protected only by the leakage promises. It suits a business with reliable accounts and a short gap to completion.

Need help with the price terms in a share sale?

If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with a share sale and its price adjustment or earn-out, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles mergers and acquisitions and share sale agreements. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.

The Raffles Corporate Services Editorial Team, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services