Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

Extension of Time and Delay Claims in Singapore: Notice, Prolongation Costs and Liquidated Damages

Several tower cranes on a construction site

If a building or fit-out project runs late in Singapore, whether the contractor gets an extension of time, and whether the developer can deduct liquidated damages, depends mainly on the contract and on the notices given while the delay was happening. A contractor that misses a notice condition can still be charged liquidated damages even if the employer caused part of the delay. Extra money for prolongation is a separate claim that needs its own contractual basis.

Several tower cranes on a construction site
A delayed project raises extension of time and prolongation cost claims. Photo by Artem Labunsky on Unsplash.

What does an extension of time actually do?

An extension of time (EOT) moves the contract completion date. It does not by itself pay the contractor anything. Its main job is to protect the contractor from liquidated damages, the daily sum the contract says is payable for every day the works finish after the completion date. It also keeps the employer’s right to charge those damages alive, because a clear, updated completion date is what the clause runs against.

Most commercial building contracts in Singapore, including those based on the SIA conditions or public sector forms such as PSSCOC, contain an EOT clause that lists the events that qualify, such as employer-ordered variations, late access to site or late instructions. The list and the notice steps are in your contract, so start there rather than with general principles.

Which delay events usually earn time, and which earn money?

Standard forms usually sort delay events into three groups. The table below is a general pattern only. Your contract may group events differently, so check the clause wording.

Type of delay event Examples Typical position
Employer risk Late site access, late drawings or instructions, employer-ordered variations, suspension by the employer Extension of time, and often additional cost if the contract has a loss and expense or similar clause
Neutral events Exceptionally adverse weather, force majeure type events listed in the contract, some statutory changes Extension of time only, no extra money
Contractor risk Shortage of labour or materials, defective work, a subcontractor’s failure, the contractor’s own poor planning No extension and no extra cost, and liquidated damages can run

The reason time and money are treated separately is that an EOT only relieves the contractor of the duty to finish by the old date. Prolongation costs, such as extended site staff, site overheads and plant hire, are recoverable only where the contract allows them or the employer’s breach caused them, and the contractor must show the loss with evidence.

What happens if the contractor gives late or no notice of delay?

This is the most contested point in practice. Many EOT clauses require written notice within a stated number of days of a delay event, and some make notice a condition precedent to the extension. In Diamond Glass Enterprise Pte Ltd v Zhong Kai Construction Co Pte Ltd [2022] SGHC(A) 44, the Appellate Division of the High Court held that a contractor must satisfy a condition precedent like this to obtain an extension. It also held that non-compliance does not stop the employer from claiming liquidated damages, and that time is not set at large merely because the contractor did not comply. The court declined to follow the Australian decision in Gaymark, which had gone the other way.

The practical lesson for contractors is that a delay the employer genuinely caused is not a safe harbour if the notice was never given. The lesson for employers is that strict notice clauses are enforceable tools, but they should be applied consistently and the employer should not itself behave in a way that makes the clause meaningless, for example by ordering late changes without any mechanism to reset the date.

Can the employer lose the right to liquidated damages altogether?

Yes, in a narrower situation. Under the prevention principle, an employer cannot hold a contractor to a completion date that the employer itself made impossible to meet. Where the contract has no way to extend time for employer-caused delay, the risk is that time is set “at large” and the liquidated damages clause cannot be applied, leaving the employer to claim general damages for unreasonable delay. The Appellate Division discussed this in Ng Koon Yee Mickey v Mah Sau Cheong [2022] SGHC(A) 33, noting that time is set at large as a consequence of an act of prevention and that delay in completion must actually be proven first.

An EOT clause that covers employer delay is the contract’s answer to that problem. That is why a clause that works, with notice applied in the way described above, usually keeps liquidated damages enforceable. You can read how a court tests the clause itself, including the penalty rule, in our guide to liquidated damages in Singapore.

How does a court assess how much extra time is fair?

The Court of Appeal in CAJ v CAI [2021] SGCA 102 treated an extension of time defence as fact-sensitive. The contractor must identify the act or default relied on, explain how it delayed the works, show what extension fairly reflects that delay, and show reasonable efforts to minimise the delay. The court also found no legal basis for cutting an extension by a percentage of “fault”, because the question is what period fairly reflects the delay actually caused. It repeated that the requirement of contemporaneous notice with particulars may operate as a condition precedent.

In practice, this means the programme records matter more than the correspondence arguing about blame. Where two causes overlap, such as an employer’s late instruction and the contractor’s own labour shortage in the same weeks, the contract wording decides how that period is treated, so take advice before relying on any approach.

How do liquidated damages work after termination?

Liquidated damages are for delay in finishing the works. In Diamond Glass, the Appellate Division held that, absent special wording, liquidated damages stop accruing on termination, though the right to damages for the period before termination survives. If the contractor is terminated, the employer’s later costs of completing the work through another contractor are usually claimed as general damages, not as more liquidated damages. Our article on terminating a contract for breach covers the steps and the risk of a wrongful termination.

What should a contractor or developer do, step by step?

  1. Read the EOT, notice and loss and expense clauses and note every deadline in days.
  2. Give written notice of each delay event within the stated period, even where you are unsure of its effect on the date. Notices are cheap, and a missed one can be expensive.
  3. Follow with the particulars the clause requires, such as the number of days claimed and the activities affected on the programme.
  4. Keep the programme updated and keep daily site records, so a delay analysis can be built later.
  5. Separate your claim for time from your claim for cost, and attach cost evidence to the second.
  6. If you are the employer, respond within the contract’s period, give a reasoned decision and update the completion date, so the liquidated damages clause stays workable.
  7. Before deducting liquidated damages, check that notices were given, the date was properly set and the sum was a genuine estimate.

Example: a delayed fit-out

Example: A company hires a contractor for an office fit-out due in 20 weeks, with liquidated damages of S$1,000 a day. In week eight the company instructs a layout change. The contractor gives no notice, completes 30 days late, and the company deducts S$30,000. Under the approach in Diamond Glass, the missed notice means the contractor is unlikely to reduce the deduction by pointing to the layout change, if the contract made notice a condition. If the contractor had given notice, a 20-day extension might have reduced the deduction to S$10,000, and the layout change might also have supported a claim for the extra site costs. This is a hypothetical example, not a prediction of any dispute.

Which documents should you gather?

If a dispute ends up as a payment claim, the Security of Payment Act process has short deadlines. Our guides on responding to a payment claim and on adjudication explain the steps. If the delay has left defects behind, see defects liability and retention.

Frequently asked questions

Does an extension of time mean the contractor gets paid more?

No. An EOT is about time. Money for prolongation depends on the contract’s cost clause or on a breach by the employer, and must be proven.

Can an employer charge liquidated damages if it caused the delay?

If the contract has a working EOT clause and the contractor did not follow its notice steps, Diamond Glass indicates the employer may still claim. If there is no way to extend time for employer delay, the clause may fail under the prevention principle.

Do liquidated damages need proof of actual loss?

No, they are a pre-agreed sum, but the clause must not be a penalty. See our liquidated damages guide for the test.

Can a verbal instruction count as notice?

Only if the contract allows it. Most require written notice, so confirm any verbal instruction or warning by email or letter straight away.

How long do we have to sue over project delay?

Contract claims are generally subject to a six-year limitation period under the Limitation Act 1959, but contract notice periods and adjudication deadlines are much shorter and may be lost first.

Can a company claim from a subcontractor for delay caused by the subcontractor?

Often yes, under the subcontract’s terms, but the subcontract has to be read on its own. Our guide on third party claims explains how a defendant can bring in a party who caused the problem.

Need help with a delayed project dispute?

If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with a delayed construction or fit-out project, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles construction and commercial disputes. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.

The Raffles Corporate Services Editorial Team, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services