Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

Overpaid Tax in an Earlier Year? Section 93A Relief for Error or Mistake and the Four-Year Window

A calculator and a pen on a sheet of paper

If your company paid too much income tax because of its own error in a return or statement, section 93A of the Income Tax Act 1947 lets it apply to IRAS for relief, either as a repayment or as an amendment to the assessment. IRAS says the application must be in writing and made no later than four years after the end of the Year of Assessment in which the assessment was made. The clock depends on where the error started, so check the date before anything else.

A calculator and a pen on a sheet of paper
A company that overpaid tax in an earlier year may be able to claim relief. Photo by Aaron Lefler on Unsplash.

What does section 93A actually cover?

Section 93A applies where a person says that, for a Year of Assessment, an assessment is excessive because of an error or mistake in a return or statement, or that an unabsorbed loss, allowance or donation that can be carried forward ought to be higher. After receiving the application, the Comptroller of Income Tax inquires into it and gives whatever relief appears reasonable and just, by repayment of tax or amendment of the assessment.

It is a relief for mistakes in what your company told IRAS. Typical examples are a deductible expense left out of the computation, a capital allowance not claimed, income entered twice, or a carry-forward balance understated. It is not a route for disagreeing with how IRAS applied the law to a correct return. That dispute belongs in an objection, which is covered in our guide to objecting to a company Notice of Assessment.

Who can claim and by when?

IRAS’s guidance for companies says a company may apply for relief for an error or mistake in the tax return or statement submitted for any Year of Assessment, subject to conditions, by applying in writing not later than 4 years after the end of the YA within which the assessment was made. The key is the source of the error, not the year the money was actually paid.

Situation (IRAS examples) Where the error is Claim deadline
YA 2021 return contains the error; one Notice of Assessment issued in 2022 Original return 31 December 2026
Same, but IRAS issued an additional or amended assessment in 2023 based on a further statement Original return Still 31 December 2026
Original return correct, assessed in 2022; a later statement with an error led to an amended assessment in 2023 The later statement 31 December 2027

In other words, the four years run from the end of the YA in which the relevant assessment was made. If your error sits in a return assessed in 2022, the window closes at the end of this year, so act now rather than after the year-end rush.

What counts as an error or mistake, and what does not?

The statute does not define the phrase, and in AQP v Comptroller of Income Tax [2013] SGCA 3 the Court of Appeal expressly declined to comment on the scope of section 93A because it was not before it. The case concerned a company that had not claimed a loss caused by its former managing director’s misappropriation and then sought relief under section 93A. The boundaries are therefore decided case by case by IRAS and, if disputed, the Board of Review.

The Act also contains a specific carve-out. No relief by repayment of tax is given for an error or mistake as to the basis on which the liability ought to have been computed, where the return was in fact made on the basis of, or in accordance with, the Comptroller’s practice generally prevailing at the time. Where the point is a matter of judgment, such as whether an item is capital or revenue, expect IRAS to scrutinise whether it was a true slip or a position that was simply taken.

Practically, your application is strongest when it shows a factual or computational slip, explains how it happened, and attaches the evidence that proves the corrected figure.

How do we prepare and make the claim?

  1. Identify the YA and the notices. List every Notice of Assessment for the YA with its date. This fixes the deadline.
  2. Find the error’s origin. Decide whether it was in the original return or in a later statement, using the IRAS examples above.
  3. Recompute. Prepare the corrected tax computation and show the difference line by line against what was filed.
  4. Check carry-on effects. A change in one year can alter capital allowance pools and loss balances in later years, so trace them forward.
  5. Write to IRAS. Apply in writing, explain the error, quantify the overpayment and attach the support. IRAS’s page does not prescribe a form or list the documents, so give a full explanation and evidence rather than a bare request.
  6. Keep proof of submission. Note the date sent and the reference IRAS gives you.
  7. Review the response. If IRAS refuses or grants only part, take advice promptly on the next step.

Example: an unclaimed capital allowance

Example: a hypothetical company bought equipment in its financial year ended 31 December 2020 but its tax preparer left the purchase out of the YA 2021 computation. The company received its Notice of Assessment for YA 2021 in 2022 and noticed the omission only in November 2026 while reviewing its fixed asset register. Because the error is in the original return assessed in 2022, its deadline under the IRAS example is 31 December 2026. It recomputes the allowance for YA 2021, checks the effect on later years, and writes to IRAS before the deadline with the purchase invoice, the asset register and the revised computation. The figures and outcome are illustrative only. Whether relief is given is IRAS’s decision.

Documents checklist

How is this different from an objection or a voluntary disclosure?

Route Use it when Direction
Section 93A relief Your own error or mistake caused an excessive assessment You overpaid
Objection You disagree with the assessment within the objection period stated on the notice, see what follows if IRAS refuses Either, but timing is much shorter
Voluntary disclosure An error meant too little tax was paid, see why disclosures fail You underpaid

The same four-year idea limits how far back IRAS itself can usually reopen a year, as explained in our note on IRAS time limits. GST errors follow a separate process and are outside section 93A.

Frequently asked questions

We missed the four-year limit. Is there any other way to recover the tax?

Section 93A itself is time-limited. Speak to a tax adviser about whether any other provision fits your facts, because the answer depends on the circumstances and we would not assume a remedy exists.

Does the error need to be large?

The wording of section 93A does not set a minimum amount. Cost and effort still matter, so weigh the tax involved against the work of a proper application.

Does our accounting error also need correcting in the financial statements?

Often yes. A prior-period error can affect both the accounts and the tax computation, see correcting a prior-period error. The accounting correction and the IRAS claim are separate steps.

Can an adviser’s mistake qualify?

The statute speaks of error or mistake in the return or statement and does not exclude a preparer’s mistake. Whether a particular lapse qualifies is for IRAS to decide on the facts, so describe plainly what went wrong.

Will IRAS pay interest on a refund?

We have not verified IRAS’s position on interest for section 93A repayments, so do not assume any. Ask IRAS when you apply.

Need help with an overpaid tax claim?

If you think your company overpaid tax in an earlier year, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133. We can review the filed computation, prepare the corrected computation and supporting schedules, and help with the written application to IRAS. Whether relief is given is decided by IRAS.

Kevin Yeo, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services