Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

Stop Misuse of Confidential Business Information in Singapore: The First 48 Hours

A red padlock on a black computer keyboard

If you discover that a departing employee, business partner or competitor is misusing your confidential information, the first 48 hours decide how strong your position is. Secure and record the evidence without alerting the person, cut off access, identify exactly what was taken, and get advice on whether to send a firm demand letter or apply to court for an urgent interim injunction. Courts expect speed, and delay can weaken a request for urgent relief.

A red padlock on a black computer keyboard
A company that finds its confidential information being misused needs to act fast. Photo by FlyD on Unsplash.

What legal route protects confidential business information?

The main civil route is breach of confidence, which is a claim in equity. It can apply even where there is no contract with the person, for example a competitor that knowingly receives your pricing model. Contracts, such as an NDA or an employment contract with a confidentiality clause, add a second route. Other possible routes include breach of the duty of good faith by an employee still in service, and, where personal data is involved, data protection duties.

The Court of Appeal modified the traditional test in I-Admin (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Hong Ying Ting [2020] SGCA 32. Where the information is confidential and was received in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence, a breach is presumed and the defendant must rebut it. The court also recognised the claimant’s interest in avoiding wrongful loss, so proof that the information was actually used is not always necessary. Our article on a former employee taking your clients and confidential information explains restrictive covenants, which we do not repeat here.

This article is different in focus: it is a response plan for the moment of discovery, whoever the other person is.

What should the company do in the first 48 hours?

Window Action Why it matters
Hour 0 to 4 Limit who knows. Appoint one internal lead and one person to log events Prevents tipping off and keeps one version of the facts
Hour 0 to 4 Suspend or restrict the person’s access to systems, cloud folders, CRM, email and building access, in line with HR advice Stops further copying
Hour 4 to 12 Preserve logs, emails, device images and cloud audit trails. Do not browse or modify the person’s laptop Opening files alters metadata and can undermine evidence
Hour 12 to 24 Identify what was taken and rank it: customer data, pricing, source code, formulas, tenders Courts want a specific description of the information, not a vague claim
Hour 12 to 24 Collect the documents that create the duty: contract, NDA, policies, access approvals Shows the obligation of confidence
Hour 24 to 36 Take advice on a demand letter versus court action The letter can be quick, but it warns the other side
Hour 36 to 48 Prepare the board decision and, if needed, the draft affidavit Urgent applications depend on clear sworn evidence

What evidence should you gather, and how?

Think in layers: what existed, who had access, what was copied, and where it went.

  1. Identify the information. Describe it by category and give examples, such as the customer price list for a named product line.
  2. Show that it is confidential. Access restrictions, passwords, marking, an NDA, internal policy and limited circulation all help.
  3. Preserve system logs. Email gateway records, file download logs, USB and cloud upload logs, VPN access, printer logs and badge records can show unusual activity before resignation or termination.
  4. Preserve the devices. Ask an IT forensics provider to image laptops and phones rather than using them. Keep a chain of custody record with names, times and storage details.
  5. Capture the other side’s use. Screenshots of a competitor’s website, offers to your customers or tender documents, with date and URL, help show use. Our guide to WhatsApp messages as evidence sets out how to keep messages in a usable form.
  6. Consider a preservation order. Where the other side may destroy material, see our article on a court order to preserve evidence.

Do not log in to the person’s personal accounts, guess passwords or secretly access private messages. Doing so can create legal problems for the company and can taint the evidence.

Should you send a cease and desist letter or go to court?

A letter of demand is quick and cheap, and many cases settle on an undertaking not to use or disclose the material, to return or delete it and to confirm what was shared. It also puts the other side on notice. The risk is that a dishonest recipient may delete evidence or move the information before you act. Read our guide on sending a cease and desist letter before drafting one.

If the risk is that the information will be used or disclosed immediately, for example before a tender closes or a client meeting, an application for an interim injunction may be needed. Interim injunctions are governed by Order 13 of the Rules of Court 2021. The court has applied the American Cyanamid approach in Singapore: is there a serious question to be tried, and where does the balance of convenience lie, including whether damages would be an adequate remedy. Restraint of trade cases can follow a different approach, so the type of clause matters.

Applicants must usually give an undertaking to compensate the other side if the injunction later proves unjustified. The Court of Appeal has said, in a freezing order context, that the undertaking must not be illusory ([2023] SGCA 27), and a company should expect the court to ask whether it can support it. If the application is made without notice to the other side, there is a strict duty to give full and frank disclosure, including facts against you. Our article on springboard injunctions covers one common form of interim relief.

Does it matter whether the person is an employee, partner or competitor?

Example: the tender pricing file

Example: An engineering services company learns on a Monday that its estimator resigned on Friday and has joined a rival that is bidding in the same tender, closing on Thursday. IT logs show 400 files uploaded to a personal cloud account the night before resignation, including the pricing model for the tender.

On Monday the company locks the estimator’s accounts, preserves the logs and images the laptop. On Tuesday it lists the files that matter and gathers the contract and confidentiality policy. By Wednesday the board decides, on advice, to ask for undertakings through a letter sent to the estimator and to the rival, and to prepare an urgent application in case the undertakings are refused. The tender deadline explains why a letter alone would be risky, and why records made in the first two days matter.

Documents checklist for the first meeting with a lawyer

Frequently asked questions

Do we need a signed NDA to claim breach of confidence?

No. A duty of confidence can arise in equity without a written contract, though a signed document makes proof much easier.

Can we search the employee’s personal phone?

No, not without lawful authority or consent. Limit your review to company systems, and speak to a lawyer about any request for access to personal devices.

How quickly must we act to get an interim injunction?

There is no fixed number of days, but courts look at delay when deciding whether the matter is truly urgent. Prepare the evidence immediately after discovery.

Is it enough to show the employee copied files?

It can be strong evidence. Under I-Admin, actual use does not always need to be proved, but you should still show the information was confidential and the circumstances of the taking.

Does a restrictive covenant help?

It may, but only if it is reasonable and enforceable. Breach of confidence is a separate claim that does not depend on a covenant. Check the employment contract terms early.

Need help with misuse of your confidential information?

If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with misuse of confidential business information, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles confidentiality and injunction matters. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.

The Raffles Corporate Services Editorial Team, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services