Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

A Director Will Not Resign: Agree an Exit or Move to Removal

White and grey office chairs around a table

If a director will not resign, you have two routes: agree an exit on paper, or remove the director by shareholder resolution. A director cannot be forced to sign a resignation letter, but in most private companies the shareholders who hold the majority of votes can remove a director under section 152 of the Companies Act, subject to the company’s constitution and any shareholders’ agreement. Start by finding out why the director is refusing, because the answer decides whether a negotiated exit is realistic or you should move to the formal route.

White and grey office chairs around a table
Shareholders have set routes when a director refuses to resign. Photo by Danielle Cerullo on Unsplash.

Why a director refuses to resign

A refusal is rarely about the title. The usual reasons are practical, and each points to a different response:

Can the company make a director resign?

No. A resignation is the director’s own act. What the company can do is remove the director, which does not need the director’s agreement. Under the Companies Act, a private company can generally remove a director by ordinary resolution of its shareholders, while public companies face a stricter procedure with special notice. Whether your company can rely on that power depends on its constitution and on any shareholders’ agreement, which can add voting thresholds, investor nomination rights or consent requirements. Our guides on removing a director from a private company and how section 152 works cover the removal steps. This article deals with the stage before that: deciding between exit terms and removal.

Which route fits your situation?

Situation Better first step Watch for
The director wants money or a release before leaving Negotiated exit with a signed resignation and release Do not pay before the resignation is signed and filed
The director is a minority shareholder and uncooperative Removal by ordinary resolution The constitution or shareholders’ agreement may protect the seat
The director represents an investor Check nomination rights first, then talk to the investor Removal may breach the agreement even if the vote passes
The director holds half the votes Negotiation, or the dispute clauses in the agreement An ordinary resolution may not pass; legal advice is likely needed
The director is also an employee Deal with board seat and employment separately Removal as director does not end the employment contract
The director is the only resident director Appoint a replacement first The company must keep at least one ordinarily resident director

How do you negotiate a voluntary exit?

A written exit agreement protects both sides, and it is usually quicker than a contested removal. Points to settle in writing:

  1. Effective date. State the date the resignation takes effect and that the director will sign the resignation notice.
  2. Handover. The director returns laptops, files, seals, registers and any company documents, and gives up Corppass and bank access. See our article on removing Corppass access after a director leaves.
  3. Guarantees and bank mandates. If the director signed personal guarantees, the release is a separate negotiation with the bank or landlord. Our checklists on bank mandate changes and a director who remains a guarantor are relevant here.
  4. Money. Settle unpaid fees, loans and any share purchase, with payment tied to the signed resignation.
  5. Release and conduct. Mutual releases, confidentiality and non-disparagement can be agreed. They should be drafted so as not to cut across statutory duties.
  6. Shares. Resigning as a director does not change shareholding. If the shares are also changing hands, record that separately.

Ask the director to sign the resignation notice at the same time as the exit agreement, so the filing does not depend on goodwill later.

What does ACRA require when a director does resign?

According to ACRA, a director can resign only if the resignation follows the company’s constitution and the company will still have at least one director who is ordinarily resident in Singapore. The company must withdraw the director through Bizfile within 14 days of the resignation. If the company does not do so, the director can notify ACRA directly. Late reporting can lead to fines, so file promptly. The date of resignation matters in disputes, as discussed in our note on a disputed resignation date.

If the director has already stopped attending and says they have resigned, but nothing was filed, keep the written notice, the date it was received and any messages. The company should file the cessation, and the director also has the right to notify ACRA directly.

What if the director still refuses?

  1. Read the constitution and shareholders’ agreement. Look for removal thresholds, nomination rights, quorum rules and notice periods.
  2. Count the votes. Check the register of members to see who can pass an ordinary resolution.
  3. Make sure the company still has a resident director. Appoint a replacement before the removal takes effect.
  4. Call and hold the meeting properly. Give the notice the Companies Act and constitution require, and let the director attend and speak.
  5. File the change with ACRA. Record the removal and update the registers and bank mandate.
  6. Change access. Remove Corppass, email, system and signing authority on the same day.

A removed director who is a shareholder can sometimes allege unfair treatment and apply to court, including under section 216 of the Companies Act. Courts look at the facts, so keep a clear record of the reasons and the process.

What should the company avoid doing?

Pressure tactics tend to backfire and can create claims that did not exist before. In particular:

Example: a founder who will not step down

Example (hypothetical). A trading company has three directors who are also shareholders: two hold 70 percent together and a third holds 30 percent. The third director stops working in the business but will not resign, saying she wants her shares bought first. The constitution has no special protection for directors. The two majority shareholders offer a resignation in exchange for a share buy-out at an agreed valuation, with payment due after the signed resignation is filed. She declines. They then propose an ordinary resolution to remove her, after appointing a new resident director, and give proper notice. Her shares are untouched, and she keeps any rights as a minority shareholder.

Documents checklist

Frequently asked questions

Does the director have to sign a resignation letter?

No one can be compelled to resign. The company can remove the director by resolution instead, if the constitution and agreements permit.

Can the board remove a fellow director?

Only if the constitution gives the board that power. The statutory power to remove sits with the shareholders.

Do we need a reason to remove a director?

The statutory power for a private company does not require a stated reason, but the director may have contractual or unfair treatment claims, so a record of the business reason helps.

Does removal end the director’s employment?

No. Board seat and employment are separate. See our article on removing a director who is also an employee.

Can the director keep their shares?

Yes, unless the constitution, a shareholders’ agreement or a leaver clause says otherwise. See removing a co-founder with no leaver clause.

Need help with a director who will not resign?

If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with a director who will not resign, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles company and shareholder disputes. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.

Willie Tan, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services