Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

Legal Professional Privilege for a Company: Sharing Advice With Auditors, Insurers and Investors Without Waiver

A stack of thick folders on a white surface

Legal professional privilege lets a company keep certain confidential legal communications and litigation material away from the other side and the court. In Singapore it covers legal advice privilege and litigation privilege. Your company can lose that protection by sharing documents carelessly, for example with auditors, insurers, investors or in an internal report that is later circulated. Decide who needs to see privileged material, record why, and share it only on written confidentiality terms.

A stack of thick folders on a white surface
Confidential legal advice can lose its protection if a company shares it carelessly. Photo by Beatriz Pérez Moya on Unsplash.

What does privilege protect for a company?

Singapore recognises two main kinds.

The leading Court of Appeal decision is Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken AB (Publ), Singapore Branch v Asia Pacific Breweries (Singapore) Pte Ltd and Other Appeals [2007] SGCA 9. The Court said a corporate client can claim privilege, but only for communications made by employees who are authorised to seek legal advice. It adopted the dominant purpose test for litigation privilege and said litigation must be reasonably in prospect, which is more than a mere possibility. It also said a bare assertion of privilege is not enough, because the court examines the evidence.

Privilege protects communications and advice, not underlying facts. Your company cannot hide a contract, an invoice or a fact by sending it to a lawyer.

Is advice from our in-house counsel privileged?

It can be. Section 128A extends privilege to confidential communications with in-house legal counsel. The usual points are that the communication must be confidential, that the person must be giving legal advice or assistance as legal counsel, and that the person must have the legal expertise, which in practice usually means being eligible to practise as a Singapore-qualified lawyer. Commentary on the case law notes that the exact scope has been tested in the courts, so take advice if in-house advice is central to a dispute.

The company can do much to protect the position. Keep legal advice separate from business and commercial discussion, mark advice clearly as legal advice, and limit circulation to people who need it. A manager with a title of “legal” and no legal qualification is not a safe basis for privilege.

When does sharing a document waive privilege?

Privilege belongs to the client, and only the client can waive it. A lawyer may disclose privileged material only with the client’s express consent. Waiver usually arises when the company, or someone with authority, discloses the content in a way that destroys confidentiality or uses it against the other side. Commentary on Singapore law notes these general points: privilege is lost if material becomes public, for example by being filed in open court; disclosure to the opposing party can waive privilege; and disclosure to a third party does not necessarily waive privilege if made on the express condition that the information remains confidential.

That last point is the practical tool. Before sharing, agree in writing that the recipient will keep the material confidential and use it only for the stated purpose.

Who can the company safely share advice with?

There is no single safe answer, and some points are not settled by the sources we checked. The table gives a cautious working guide. Have a lawyer review any plan to share privileged material outside the company.

Recipient Main risk Safer approach
Directors and authorised managers Wide internal circulation weakens confidentiality Circulate on a need-to-know basis and mark it privileged
Related companies in the group Treated as separate persons Written confidentiality terms and a clear shared purpose; take advice
Auditors They may need the substance for provisions and disclosures Give a factual summary of the claim and its status instead of the advice itself, and agree confidentiality in writing
Insurers Policy may require disclosure of reports Check the policy, agree confidentiality terms and take advice before sending any lawyer’s report
Investors, lenders or buyers in due diligence Disclosure to a counterparty may waive privilege Disclose facts and status, not advice, unless the lawyer confirms a protected route
The other side in a dispute Waiver of the document, and possibly related material Do not disclose without advice. Ask for return of anything sent by mistake

How do you avoid waiver in an internal investigation?

An internal investigation often creates documents the company later wants to keep private. The risk is that the report serves several purposes, such as regulatory reporting, insurer updates and board information, and privilege is lost on the way. In Skandinaviska the Court looked at the dominant purpose of draft reports and found that fact-finding and internal control purposes were subsidiary to litigation, but that outcome depended on the evidence, not on the label.

  1. Define the purpose in writing. Record, at the start, that the investigation is to obtain legal advice or to prepare for anticipated litigation, and identify the litigation.
  2. Route it through lawyers. Engage the lawyer first, and have the lawyer instruct any forensic accountant or consultant.
  3. Control circulation. Keep a distribution list. Do not forward the report to staff, customers or regulators by default.
  4. Separate facts from advice. If the company needs to give a factual account to a regulator, insurer or auditor, prepare it separately from the legal analysis.
  5. Label carefully. A “privileged and confidential” header helps as evidence of intent, but it does not create privilege.
  6. Review before any disclosure. A lawyer should check what is being released and on what terms.

If a third party such as a former employee may hold your confidential material, our guide to a former employee taking clients and confidential information explains the separate duty of confidence.

How does privilege work once a lawsuit starts?

In discovery and document production, the company must identify privileged documents and withhold them properly, and must not hand them over by accident. Our guides on producing electronic documents in company litigation and getting documents from a non-party explain the document stages. Before documents are exchanged, have a lawyer review them for privilege, particularly emails and WhatsApp chats where legal advice is mixed with business talk.

If privileged material is sent by mistake, tell your lawyer immediately. Commentary on Singapore law indicates that where disclosure was limited in purpose or inadvertent, and the document has not yet been used, the receiving party may be prevented from relying on it, but prompt action matters.

Privilege is different from “without prejudice” protection for settlement discussions. That is covered in our guide to without prejudice letters.

What should the company keep on file?

Example: a supplier fraud review

Example: A company discovers that a procurement manager may have been paid by a supplier. The directors instruct a lawyer, who engages a forensic accountant, with a written note that the work is to advise on a possible claim against the supplier. The lawyer’s advice goes to two directors only. The company’s auditor asks about the matter. The finance director gives the auditor a short factual summary of the amounts involved and the status of the claim, signed under a confidentiality agreement, and does not send the advice. Later the supplier asks for all documents about the review. The company can explain which documents it withholds as privileged, and why, because the purpose and circulation are on record.

Frequently asked questions

Are emails with our lawyer always privileged?

No. They must be confidential and made to seek or give legal advice. Business or administrative emails copied to a lawyer are less likely to qualify.

Can we forward our lawyer’s advice to the board?

Usually yes, if it is limited to people who need it and kept confidential. Avoid circulating it widely or discussing it in non-legal settings.

Does a “privileged” label protect a document?

No. The label is only evidence of intention. The document must meet the requirements for legal advice or litigation privilege.

Is advice from an accountant or company secretary privileged?

Not on its own. Privilege attaches to communications with lawyers, and to third-party work in some cases where it is part of obtaining legal advice or preparing for litigation. Take advice before relying on this.

What if a privileged document is disclosed by mistake?

Tell your lawyer at once. Ask the recipient in writing to return or delete it and not to use it. The court may prevent its use in some cases, but delay makes this harder.

Need help with legal professional privilege?

If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with legal professional privilege, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles litigation and privilege issues. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.

The Raffles Corporate Services Editorial Team, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services