
If your contract says the parties must negotiate or mediate before arbitration or court, skipping that step does not make the claim disappear, but it can cause real delay and cost. The other side may ask for a stay, argue the claim is premature, or say the tribunal cannot hear it. How the point is treated depends on the clause wording, the forum and the facts. The safest course is to follow the steps, or to get the other side’s written waiver before you file.

What is a tiered dispute clause?
A tiered (or multi-tier) clause sets out steps for resolving a dispute, in order. A common sequence is: notify the dispute, escalate to senior management, mediate, then arbitrate or litigate. Our guide to dispute resolution clauses for SME contracts explains how such clauses are drafted. This article deals with the other problem: what follows if someone moves to the final step too early.
Does skipping a step stop the claim?
Not automatically, and the answer differs by forum. Singapore courts have taken different approaches over time, so check current authority for your case rather than rely on a single rule.
- Clear, mandatory steps matter. In International Research Corp PLC v Lufthansa Systems Asia Pacific Pte Ltd [2013] SGCA 55 (also reported at [2014] 1 SLR 130), the Court of Appeal treated specific, mandatory steps as conditions precedent to arbitration. The clause named who had to meet and why. The required people had not met, and the Court held that the arbitration agreement could not be invoked, so the tribunal lacked jurisdiction over the party concerned. That was one of two independent grounds for allowing the appeal.
- Later High Court thinking. In DRO v DRP [2025] SGHC 255, the High Court held that non-compliance with a pre-arbitration step goes to admissibility (whether the claim should be heard now) and not to jurisdiction (the tribunal’s power). It viewed the earlier Court of Appeal comments on that point as not binding. Commentary on the case suggests the likely result of non-compliance is a stay pending compliance, and possibly damages, not an outright dismissal. The wording of a particular clause could still lead to a different result.
The practical lesson: a skipped step is a serious risk and a bargaining chip for the other side, but it does not always end the claim. It can also be cured, for example by completing the step later.
How might the other side use a skipped step?
| Forum | What the other side may argue | What the claimant should expect |
|---|---|---|
| Arbitration seated in Singapore | The tribunal lacks jurisdiction, or the claim is inadmissible until the step is done | A preliminary ruling. A jurisdiction ruling can usually be challenged in court, so timing and cost grow |
| Court proceedings despite an arbitration clause | The court case should be stayed in favour of arbitration | A stay application. The Arbitration Act 2001 s 6 and the International Arbitration Act 1994 s 6 govern stays, and the court’s discretion differs between them |
| Court proceedings with a mediation step | The case should be paused until mediation takes place | The Mediation Act 2017 contains a stay power where parties agreed to mediate, and courts have used it |
| Negotiation or escalation step only | The step was a precondition, so the claim is premature | The result depends on how clear and certain the wording is |
For a domestic arbitration agreement, the Court of Appeal in CSY v CSZ [2022] SGCA 43 confirmed that under s 6(2) of the Arbitration Act the court may stay proceedings only if it is satisfied there is no sufficient reason why the matter should not be referred to arbitration, and that the applicant was and remains ready and willing to arbitrate. In that case the Court refused a stay, mainly because of overlapping disputes and the risk of inconsistent findings, and not because of the tiers. It shows the court looks at the whole picture.
What should you do before filing?
- Read the clause closely. Note each step, who must take it, any time limits and whether the wording is “shall” or “may”.
- Check what has already happened. Meetings, emails and WhatsApp exchanges may count as completed steps. Build a timeline.
- Send a written dispute notice. Follow the notice clause precisely. Keep proof of delivery.
- Complete or offer each step. If the other side is silent, record the offer and the date. Silence may support an argument that they cannot rely on the step.
- Ask for a written waiver. If time is short, ask the other party to confirm in writing that it will not rely on the unfinished step.
- Protect limitation. If a time limit is about to expire, take legal advice on whether to file and ask for a stay, or to agree a standstill in writing. Our guide to the limitation period for unpaid business debts explains why the clock matters.
- Consider interim relief. Urgent protection may be needed even if the steps are incomplete. Take advice before filing.
What if the step was skipped by the other side?
If your company is the one being pursued, a skipped step may be a useful point but should be raised early. Delay in objecting may suggest you accepted the process. If you do object, say so in writing and set out which step was missed and what you propose. A refusal to mediate when asked may have costs consequences in court cases, as explained in our article on mediation before litigation.
Also check whether your own conduct matters. If your company took steps in the court case without objecting, the other side may argue it waived the clause.
Does the same issue arise in shareholder disputes?
It can. Shareholders’ agreements often combine negotiation, mediation and arbitration. Whether an oppression claim is caught by the arbitration step is a separate question that we discuss in our guide to arbitration clauses and oppression claims. For the broader choice between forums, see arbitration versus litigation under the SIAC Rules 2025.
How should the clause be drafted to avoid this?
- Say clearly whether each step is mandatory and whether it is a condition precedent.
- Name roles (for example, the managing director of each party) and not just “senior management”.
- Set short, fixed time limits for each step, with an automatic move to the next step when a limit passes.
- Allow either party to seek urgent interim relief without completing the steps.
- State what happens if the other side does not engage, such as deemed completion of that step.
- Say whether limitation is paused during the steps.
Example: a supply dispute
Example: A company buys components under a contract that requires a senior-manager meeting within 14 days of a dispute notice, then mediation, then arbitration. The supplier delivers faulty parts. The company files a notice of arbitration without any meeting. The supplier objects that the steps were not followed. The company then writes to offer a meeting and a mediator, and the supplier ignores the offer. The company’s record of the offer helps it argue that the supplier cannot rely on the step, but the company has spent weeks arguing about process. Had it sent the notice and requested a meeting first, the arbitration could have started cleanly.
Frequently asked questions
Can we skip mediation if we think it is pointless?
Not safely. Unless the other side waives the step in writing or the clause allows an exception, skipping it invites a stay or jurisdiction argument. Attending a short mediation is usually cheaper than fighting about it.
Does a failed negotiation count as the step?
Often yes, if the clause only requires good-faith discussions and you can show they took place. Keep records of meetings and offers.
Is an escalation clause enforceable if it is vague?
Vague wording is harder to enforce. The Court of Appeal in the Lufthansa case relied on mandatory wording and specific, named steps. A loose promise to “try to resolve amicably” is less likely to be treated as a strict precondition.
Can the other side still arbitrate if I refuse to take part in the step?
They may argue that your refusal stops you from relying on the step. Record the refusal and take advice.
Does a stay mean the claim is lost?
No. A stay pauses the case so the agreed process can take place. Time limits may still matter, so take advice early.
Related reading: Entire Agreement Clauses in Singapore: When Side Promises and Emails Still Count.
For a related situation, read Customer Refuses to Pay and Says the Work Was Poor: How to Respond in Singapore.
Need help with a tiered dispute clause problem?
If your company, or you as a director or shareholder, is dealing with a tiered dispute clause problem, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133 or +65 9018 0072. We will help you understand the documents and deadlines. Where your matter needs a lawyer, we will refer you to a firm on our panel of Singapore law firms that regularly handles arbitration and commercial disputes. Raffles Corporate Services is a corporate services provider, not a law firm, and this article is general information, not legal advice.
The Raffles Corporate Services Editorial Team, Raffles Corporate Services
