Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

A Shareholder Objects to Your Written Resolution: The 5% Right to Force a General Meeting

A person writing on a form on a desk

If a shareholder holding at least 5% of the voting rights objects to a written resolution, the directors must call a general meeting for it. The resolution may be signed by enough members to pass, but it can still be declared invalid if the objection is made properly. Smaller shareholders cannot force a meeting, though a resolution that fails to reach its threshold within 28 days simply lapses.

A person writing on a form on a desk
Company decisions can be recorded in writing without holding a meeting. Photo by Leon Seibert on Unsplash.

Why can one shareholder interrupt a resolution that already has enough signatures?

Written resolutions exist so that a private company can decide matters without holding a meeting. Under section 184A of the Companies Act 1967, a private company can pass most resolutions by written means. As the Companies Act Steering Committee explained in its report, the threshold is a simple majority of total voting rights for an ordinary resolution, and at least 75% for a special resolution, unless the constitution asks for more. Nobody needs to agree unanimously.

That convenience would be unfair to minority shareholders if they could never be heard. So section 184D gives members holding 5% of the voting rights the right to give notice to the directors requiring that a general meeting be convened instead of proceeding by writing. The Steering Committee described this as a safeguard for minority interests, and said the directors must convene the meeting once they receive the notice.

This article is about that moment: the resolution is circulating, the majority has signed or is about to, and a member says “I object, call a meeting.” If you want the basics of signatures and records instead, read our guide to section 184A written resolutions and our step-by-step preparation guide.

What does the Singapore High Court say about a resolution that is objected to?

The leading decision is Affle Global Pte Ltd v OSLabs Pte Ltd and another and another matter [2022] SGHC 65, available on elitigation.sg. In that case, a company circulated written resolutions to approve a sale of most of its shares. Roughly 69% to 72% of the shares were signed on the first, and about 90% on a second. A shareholder that had not signed objected a few days later and invoked section 184D, asking for a general meeting.

The company’s resolutions were later declared invalid under section 184D(2), which says that a resolution subject to a valid notice is invalid even though it may have been passed in the meantime under section 184A. The directors then had to convene a general meeting. The court also accepted that a general meeting could later approve the same matters, and it upheld the meeting’s resolutions against a technical objection.

Three practical points follow. First, the signatures you hold may not protect you if an objection is made in time. Second, a meeting is the cure, not a new lawsuit. Third, the court did not decide whether share transfers registered after the written resolutions were valid. That question went to arbitration, which shows the risk of acting too early.

Which situations call for a meeting, and which do not?

Situation Can you rely on the written resolution? What to do
Members holding 5% or more of voting rights give notice requiring a meeting No. The directors must convene a general meeting Call the meeting and hold the vote there
A holder of less than 5% objects but does not sign Yes, if the threshold is still met and the process was correct Keep the objection on file and still send that member the resolution and outcome
Not enough signatures after 28 days No. It lapses under section 184DA unless your constitution says otherwise Hold a meeting or circulate a fresh resolution
The resolution would remove a director or the auditor No. These need a meeting Follow the meeting route with special notice
Your constitution requires a higher majority or bans written resolutions on that matter Only to the extent the constitution allows Check the constitution before circulating

What should the directors do when an objection arrives?

  1. Record the date and form of the notice. Note when the company received it, who signed it, and how many shares that member holds.
  2. Check the 5% test. Compare the objector’s voting rights against the total voting rights of all members, as shown in the register of members. Shares with different voting rights, joint holders and treasury or non-voting classes can change the answer.
  3. Pause anything that depends on the resolution. Do not allot shares, register a transfer, pay a dividend or lodge forms until the position is clear.
  4. Convene the meeting if the notice is valid. Prepare the notice and agenda under your constitution. Our guides on running a Singapore general meeting and defective meetings and resolutions cover notice, quorum and minutes.
  5. Tell the signatories. The members who signed need to know that their signatures are not the final decision.
  6. Put the same resolution to the meeting. The meeting thresholds then apply. If it passes, lodge any required notices with ACRA, such as those described in our guides to filing an ordinary resolution and a special resolution.

The Act sets the time limit for giving a section 184D notice. Check the current wording on Singapore Statutes Online, or ask your corporate secretary, before you rely on a deadline.

Example

Example: Harbour Trading Pte. Ltd. is a hypothetical private company with three shareholders. Mei holds 60%, Raj holds 32% and Susan holds 8%. The directors circulate a written ordinary resolution approving a share allotment to a new investor. Mei signs the same day, which gives more than 50% of the voting rights.

Susan emails the board to say she wants a meeting. Because she holds 8%, above the 5% mark, her notice requires the directors to call a general meeting. If they proceed on Mei’s signature alone and allot shares, the resolution could later be declared invalid and the allotment could be challenged. Instead, the board holds the allotment, calls the meeting and sends Susan the papers. Mei and Raj can then vote together at the meeting, and the investor closing waits a short time.

If Susan had held 3%, her objection would not by itself force a meeting. The directors should still record it, send her the resolution and outcome, and check the constitution for any additional rights.

How do you avoid the problem next time?

Keeping the resolution papers, the register of members and the signature log together also helps if a member later asks to inspect the company’s registers and minute books.

Documents checklist

Frequently asked questions

Can a shareholder object after enough signatures have been collected?

Section 184D gives that right to members holding 5% of the voting rights, and the OSLabs case involved objections made after the resolutions had reached the required numbers. The timing rules are in the statute, so confirm them before you proceed.

Do dissenting members have to be sent the resolution?

Every member entitled to vote should receive it. Leaving a minority holder out because you already have the numbers is a risk to the resolution.

Does a lapsed resolution stop the company from trying again?

No. In OSLabs the court noted that nothing stops a company from proposing a fresh identical resolution by written means or at a meeting. A resolution that lapses simply never became a resolution, so do not treat actions taken on it as authorised.

Can I remove a director by written resolution if everyone agrees?

No. Removing a director or the auditor needs a general meeting, because those resolutions require special notice and the person affected is entitled to be heard. Use the meeting route even if every member agrees.

Can the constitution change these rules?

The constitution can set a higher majority for ordinary resolutions and can vary the 28-day lapse period. Read it first.

Need help with member resolutions and general meetings?

If you are preparing a written resolution or have received a shareholder’s objection, contact Raffles Corporate Services at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133. Our corporate secretarial team can check the register of members and constitution, prepare the resolution and notice of meeting, maintain the signature log and minutes, and lodge the required ACRA filings.

Willie Tan, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services