Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

ACRA Record Does Not Match Your Company Registers: Find the Wrong One Before You Correct It

A person holding a red pencil over white paper

When the ACRA record does not match your company’s own registers, do not file a correction yet. First find out which record is wrong. If ACRA’s record is wrong, you correct it through a Notice of Error with evidence. If your internal register or share certificate is wrong, you fix your own records. If the documents themselves disagree, you may need a new resolution or a court application before anyone can say what the true position is.

A person holding a red pencil over white paper
A wrong entry on the company record can be corrected with the right filing. Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash.

Where does your company’s information actually live?

Most mismatches come from treating three separate things as one:

  1. The ACRA register. This is the public record behind your business profile, built from what was lodged on Bizfile. It cannot be edited after lodgement. You can only ask the Registrar to correct it.
  2. The company’s own statutory registers and minute book. These include the register of members, directors, secretaries and registrable controllers. The company keeps them, and the directors answer for them. Members and others have rights to inspect some of them.
  3. The underlying documents. Resolutions, signed share transfers, share certificates, consents to act and identity documents are the evidence behind both records.

A mismatch tells you that two of the three disagree. It does not tell you which is right. That is why a correction filed in a hurry, against the wrong record, can make things worse.

Which mismatches are common, and who fixes them?

What you see Usual cause Where the fix lies
Bizfile shows a different issued share count from your register of members Allotment or transfer filed with a typing error, or never recorded internally Compare to the signed documents, then use the share transaction Notice of Error if ACRA is wrong, or correct your register if it is wrong
Officer name, address or identity details differ A change that was never reported, or entered wrongly An update of particulars on Bizfile, or the correction route if the original entry was an error
A person appears as director or secretary after they left The cessation was never filed, or was filed with the wrong date The filing correction routes in our other guides, with the resignation or consent evidence
Annual return or financial statements data looks wrong An error in the return or XBRL data A separate Notice of Error route that ACRA sets for these, with its own fee
Share certificate does not match either record Certificate issued from an old template or never updated after a transfer Sort out the register first, then reissue the certificate by proper authority
Members dispute who owns the shares A genuine disagreement, not a clerical error A lawyer or the court, not a Notice of Error

How do you work out which record is wrong?

  1. Print the current ACRA business profile. Note the transaction numbers shown for the entries that look wrong. You will need them later.
  2. Print your own registers as they stand today. Check dates of entries, not only the current totals.
  3. Gather the source documents for each disputed entry. For shares, this means the board resolution approving the allotment, the signed transfer instrument, the stamped transfer where relevant, and the share certificate. For officers, the consent to act, the resignation letter and any board resolution.
  4. Trace each entry to a document. If a document supports ACRA’s version, your register is wrong. If a document supports your register, ACRA’s record is wrong. If neither does, the problem is in the underlying acts, not just the records.
  5. Decide the route. A clerical error in a lodged form goes to ACRA as a Notice of Error. An error in the company’s own register is corrected internally, with a dated note and a director’s approval. A real dispute goes to a lawyer.
  6. Write down what happened. Keep a short file note of how the discrepancy arose, because ACRA and later auditors or investors may ask.

What does ACRA need when you correct its record?

ACRA’s guidance on correcting share transaction errors says the application is made by a position holder of the company or by a corporate service provider. It asks for the company’s UEN, the transaction number or date range, a description of the error, the incorrect information filed and the correct information. For errors beyond a clerical mistake, you must also explain why the wrong information was filed, why correction is needed, and how it will not prejudice any person.

The same page points out that the Notice of Error must be filed against the transaction in which the wrong information was lodged, such as the return of allotment, not against a later filing that merely displays it, such as the annual return. It also tells applicants to remove personal details such as date of birth, mobile number or residential address from supporting documents, because filings may become publicly accessible.

ACRA states a fee of S$60 for this share transaction route, which is not refunded if the application is rejected because the information was incomplete or inaccurate. Processing is stated as 15 working days for clerical and other errors, and up to 30 working days where data changes are needed. Fees and processing times can change, so confirm them on ACRA’s page before filing. Our detailed guides on fixing a wrong ACRA filing with a Notice of Error and on correcting a share transaction lodged wrongly take you through the filing itself.

Financial statements that did not comply with the Companies Act or accounting standards have their own route. ACRA states that it requires revised statements with a new directors’ statement, filing within 30 days of the revision date, and a fee of S$200.

When the problem is your own register

If the documents show that ACRA is right and your register is wrong, you do not need ACRA at all. The directors should correct the entry, date the correction, keep the old entry visible rather than erasing it, and note the document relied on. If the register of members is wrong in a way that affects ownership, and members do not agree, internal correction is not enough. Our guides on rectifying the register of members and the court application to rectify the register explain the options when a dispute remains.

Where the wrong entry is an officer who never agreed to be appointed, the issue is more serious than a typing error. See our article on an unauthorised change of director on ACRA.

Example

Example: A hypothetical company, Lotus Design Pte. Ltd., is preparing for a bank loan. The bank’s checker finds that the business profile shows 100,000 issued shares, but the register of members shows 110,000.

The new corporate secretary pulls the filing history and finds an allotment of 10,000 shares to a minority investor two years ago. The signed board resolution and investor’s payment record support 110,000 shares. The allotment was entered in the register but the return of allotment was filed with the wrong number. ACRA’s record is wrong, so the company files a Notice of Error against the return of allotment, attaches the resolution and bank record, and explains that no third party is prejudiced. Only after ACRA confirms the correction does the company give the bank an updated profile.

Had the documents instead supported 100,000 shares, the register would have been wrong, and the company would have corrected its own register and explained the difference to the investor.

Documents checklist

Frequently asked questions

Can I just file a new change instead of correcting the old one?

Often that makes the record worse. A new change reports a new event, so it does not erase a wrong earlier entry. Use the correction route where the original entry was an error.

Who can submit a Notice of Error?

ACRA’s share transaction guidance says a position holder of the entity or a corporate service provider can file. Our guide to changing officer particulars explains when no correction is needed because the update flows from another agency.

What if the person who filed the original form has left the company?

You can still correct it. You need the transaction number and the evidence, not the original filer. Obtain the filing history from Bizfile and rebuild the file from the source documents.

How do I stop this happening again?

Keep the registers, minute book and supporting papers together and check them against the ACRA profile once a year. Our compliance calendar helps you build a routine that checks the register each year.

Is a mismatch an offence?

It may or may not be. Failing to lodge a required change on time can lead to penalties, but a good-faith clerical error corrected promptly is a different matter. If you suspect a late or missing filing, get the facts first.

Need help reconciling your ACRA record with your company registers?

If your ACRA business profile and your registers do not agree, contact Raffles Corporate Services at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133. Our corporate secretarial team can review the filing history against your registers and source documents, prepare the Notice of Error and its evidence, update the statutory registers, and lodge the filings on Bizfile.

Willie Tan, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services