Let’s talk

Insights for your business.

VCC Auditor Resigns or Is Replaced: ACRA Consent, Notices and the Three-Month Clock

A view of city buildings in daylight

If the auditor of your variable capital company (VCC) wants to leave before the term ends, the answer depends on the VCC. A VCC that includes at least one authorised collective investment scheme needs ACRA’s consent before its auditor can resign mid-term. Once the resignation takes effect, the directors have three months to call a general meeting and appoint a replacement, and ACRA must be told of the appointment within 14 days. Other VCCs follow the ordinary notification rules but still cannot go without an auditor.

A view of city buildings in daylight
A VCC must handle a change of auditor correctly with the right filings. Photo by Pedro Lastra on Unsplash.

Why does a VCC auditor change need more care than an ordinary company’s?

Every VCC must appoint at least one auditor within three months of incorporation, and the audit exemptions in sections 205B and 205C of the Companies Act do not apply to VCCs. There is no “small company” way out. That means a gap in the audit appointment is a real problem, because the audited financial statements and the auditor’s report feed straight into the AGM and the annual return. Our guide to the first six months after VCC registration covers the original appointment. This article deals with what happens when the auditor later resigns or is replaced.

ACRA’s guides word the first-auditor deadline slightly differently (three months from incorporation in one, three months from registration in another). Treat the earlier date as your deadline.

When does an auditor need ACRA’s consent to resign?

ACRA requires consent for an early resignation from a VCC that comprises at least one collective investment scheme authorised under section 286(1) of the Securities and Futures Act 2001, or other VCCs that may be prescribed. ACRA cites section 108 of the VCC Act 2018 for these premature resignations. The rule exists because of the public interest in the audit of vehicles that take in retail money.

The table sets out the common situations.

Situation ACRA consent needed? What the VCC does
Auditor leaves at an AGM (term simply ends) No. ACRA says consent is not needed for resignation at AGMs Appoint a successor and update ACRA and the registers
Auditor resigns mid-term, VCC has an authorised scheme Yes Wait for the outcome, then follow the post-consent steps below
Auditor resigns mid-term, VCC has no authorised scheme Not under ACRA’s consent guide, which targets qualifying VCCs, PICs and their subsidiaries Follow the VCC Act and the constitution, and still notify ACRA of the change
Directors want a different auditor Consent to resign is the auditor’s application, not yours Plan the change with the incoming and outgoing auditors and the VCC’s constitution

What does the auditor have to show ACRA?

Consent is only for exceptional circumstances. ACRA lists examples: the auditor can no longer do the work to the required standard, a sole proprietor auditor’s failing health, loss of the independence needed to audit the VCC, or a parent entity (audited by a different auditor) requiring a change. ACRA may consider other circumstances too.

The auditor applies through ACRA’s General lodgement eService, pays a non-refundable $200 fee, and must disclose any disputes with the VCC’s management and anything that could undermine the integrity of the audit, such as opinion shopping or pressure to act unethically. At the same time the auditor must notify the VCC in writing and give it a copy of the written statement of reasons. ACRA’s stated approval time is two weeks after it has all the information.

If ACRA does not grant consent, the auditor must continue in office. The VCC should therefore not line up a replacement and stop cooperating with the outgoing auditor until consent is actually given.

What must the VCC do after consent is granted?

  1. Note the effective date. The resignation takes effect on the latest of the date ACRA notifies the auditor and the VCC of its consent, the date ACRA fixes, and the date the auditor specifies in the resignation notice.
  2. Send the auditor’s statement to shareholders. The VCC must send a copy of the written statement to all shareholders within 14 days, counted from when it receives the notice of resignation and the statement.
  3. Call a general meeting. The directors must call a meeting to appoint a new auditor within three months from the date of the resignation.
  4. Notify ACRA of the new appointment. The directors must do this within 14 days.
  5. Update the registers. Changes to the registers of directors, company secretaries, managers and auditors must be kept current, and ACRA’s guide treats this as a 14-day matter.

How do the 14-day updates work, and what if they are missed?

ACRA’s VCC guide says changes to appointed VCC officers, managers or auditors must be updated within 14 days of the change, and the update is free. ACRA’s common offences page lists failing to report changes to the director, manager, secretary or auditor as an offence under section 72 of the VCC Act (read with section 173A of the Companies Act), with a fine of up to $5,000 plus a default penalty, applying to both the VCC and each officer in default.

The practical point is that the new appointment and the cessation of the old one are two events. Each may need to be reflected in the VCC portal and in the VCC’s own registers. Our guide to VCC directors and key officers explains who the other officers are and why their registers matter.

What does a mid-year auditor change do to the annual cycle?

Nothing in the timetable moves because the auditor changed. Unless exempted, the VCC must still hold its AGM within six months after its financial year end and file its annual return within seven months after that year end. ACRA’s filing guide lists the documents: financial statements in PDF, financial statements for each sub-fund (if any), the Statement by Directors, and the auditor’s report, together with the investment strategy details and AGM details. At least two directors must sign where there are several, and the filing fee is $1,600.

A replacement auditor who joins late in the year has less time to understand the VCC and each sub-fund, so the board should hand over the working papers’ context early. See our guides to VCC AGM requirements and the VCC annual return step by step.

Example: an auditor of an umbrella VCC resigns four months before year end

Example: A hypothetical umbrella VCC has three sub-funds, one of which is an authorised scheme. In August its auditor tells the board that a conflict has arisen with another client and independence can no longer be maintained. The auditor applies to ACRA for consent and sends the VCC the written statement of reasons the same day.

The board does three things. It keeps the auditor engaged until consent is given, because ACRA may refuse. It asks the fund manager to prepare a handover pack covering sub-fund valuation policies, the investor register and open audit points. And it asks the company secretary to diarise the post-consent clocks. ACRA grants consent and the resignation takes effect on 10 September. The company sends the statement to shareholders by 24 September, holds a general meeting to appoint the new auditor in October, and files the appointment with ACRA within 14 days of that meeting. The dates are illustrative only. The point is that each clock starts from a different trigger.

Documents checklist for an auditor change

Frequently asked questions

Can the VCC run without an auditor for a short time?

It should not. The VCC must appoint an auditor, there is no audit exemption, and the replacement must be appointed within three months of the resignation taking effect. Treat that as an outer limit and aim to appoint much sooner.

Does the VCC pay ACRA’s $200 consent fee?

ACRA’s guide describes the $200 fee as part of the auditor’s application. The VCC’s own costs are the annual return fee and the cost of the new appointment.

Who files the new auditor’s appointment with ACRA?

The directors must notify ACRA, and ACRA’s VCC guide says directors and secretaries must report officer and auditor changes.

Does the fund manager choose the auditor?

The VCC appoints its auditor through the board and shareholders. The fund manager usually coordinates the audit day to day, but the appointment belongs to the VCC. If you are changing manager as well, read our guide on how a VCC changes fund manager.

What if ACRA refuses consent?

The auditor must continue as auditor of the VCC. The board can raise any concerns about the working relationship with the auditor, but cannot treat the auditor as gone.

Is removing an auditor the same as the auditor resigning?

No. This article covers resignation and replacement. Removal or non-reappointment is governed by the VCC Act and the VCC’s constitution, so check both with your company secretary before acting.

Need help with a VCC auditor change?

If your VCC is replacing its auditor or has just received a resignation notice, contact the Raffles Corporate Services team at [email protected] or on WhatsApp at +65 8501 7133. We can prepare the meeting notices and resolutions, keep the registers current, make the ACRA filings through the VCC portal and diarise the annual deadlines, and coordinate with your fund manager and auditors.

Willie Tan, Raffles Corporate Services

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real people. Right here in Singapore.

Let’s get to work.

Hop on Raffles Corporate Services